I was tanking Hour of Twilight on Navitas. All had been going well, and we were at the second boss, Asira Dawnslayer. Anyone who has fought her will know she drops a Smoke Bomb every now and again, meaning the tank has to take her out of it so the DPS can attack her. This I did.

However, after we killed her, a Hunter named Projex started talking a load of shit, by claiming I wasn’t taking Asira out of the smoke…

I can say without a doubt that I was taking Asira out of her Smoke Bomb. I’ve always done it, so why would I stop now?

I’ll explain what I mean by this in a moment. I made a diagram.

Also, he wasn’t standing behind me. He’s just saying that he was in order to alleviate himself of any blame. At this point, we were fighting Murozond.

And that was it. We killed Murozond, I gave him this advice and left. Now I will explain what I think happened, using my little diagram…

As you can see, I am originally standing at the position marked by the orange 1. Asira drops a smoke bomb, so I pull her backwards out of it, thus ending up at position 2.

Projex, meanwhile, has ran from the green 1 to the green 2, however his LOS (indicated by the broken line) is blocked by the Smoke Bomb. So rather than move a few feet to his left/right, he decides to accuse me of not moving Asira.

It’s times like this I wish I could record videos. Sadly uploading them would be a huge strain on my Internet connection.

No matter, I’m fairly certain that I am right about my theory. As I said earlier, I always move Asira from the Smoke Bomb, so why would I suddenly stop doing it now?